Three months after Julia C. Hester House leaders and Precinct 1 Commissioner Rodney Ellis announced a plan to donate the historic community center to Harris County, the arrangement is anything but a done deal.

The donation process, which could take months to complete, has sparked concern and frustration among community members. The recent discovery of cancer-causing contaminants in soil on the property and a surprise bill in the Texas Legislature that would make Hester House a state park have further complicated matters.

Jeremy Brown, president of Hester House’s board of directors, said every option to ensure the 80-year-old institution’s future is being explored.

“It’s an ongoing conversation, and I’m glad we’re having that conversation,” he said. “…The representation there from a political standpoint, from a philanthropic standpoint, that pleases my heart, and I appreciate it.”

Since the proposed turnover first was announced last December, community members repeatedly have expressed concerns about Hester House becoming a government-run facility and frustration over the way leaders have rolled out the proposal. 

“Hester House is a cornerstone for both our seniors and young people, providing essential services that strengthen our community,” Fifth Ward resident Savant Moore wrote in a text message to the Houston Landing. “This land is priceless — it should not be a county property, but recognized as a historical landmark.”

Dorothy Steele shows historic pictures of Hester House during an interview at Hester House, Tuesday, Nov. 19, 2024, in Houston. (Houston Landing file photo / Antranik Tavitian)

Many community members did not hear about the possibility of a county takeover until it appeared on the Harris County Commissioners Court agenda in early December. 

EARLIER: Harris County to take over Fifth Ward’s Hester House in nonprofit’s bid for sustained funding

Believing court approval of the agenda item would finalize the donation, Fifth Ward community leaders sprang into action.

“That was a move for finality,” said Joetta Stevenson, president of the Fifth Ward Super Neighborhood Council. “That was a move of actually putting a period on something. And we didn’t help write that sentence.”

Brown and Ellis later clarified that the December vote by Commissioners Court merely authorized the county and the Hester House board of directors to begin working out details of the donation. The process itself, Brown added, will take months to complete.

Community concerns

Brown has hosted two community meetings since the announcement, saying transparency would be paramount throughout the process. 

At the first meeting, held the evening of  Dec. 19, attendees criticized the evening start time, explaining that many of the seniors directly impacted by a potential donation do not drive at night and could not attend. 

Walter Mallett, a Fifth Ward resident who attended the second community meeting on Feb. 8, was not pleased with that one either. 

“I don’t think the community was properly informed about the meeting,” Mallett said. 

Held inside the Hester House gymnasium, the meeting was attended by about 50 people. Mallett said the gym would have been full had residents been properly informed.

RELATED: EPA, Union Pacific investigation finds contamination at Greater Fifth Ward community center

Fred Woods, community organizer and president of the Northwood Manor Civic Club, said frustration about the donation stems from a broader lack of trust, both with Hester House leaders and with government officials. 

“I can’t trust people I have no relationship with,” Woods said. “Relationships and rapport are built over time and interaction. I’ve had neither — the community has had none, little to none.”

Financial realities

The proposed donation of Hester House’s assets would allow Harris County to fully assume maintenance and operation costs for the community center, Brown said.

Harris County Precinct 1 already funds more than 90 percent of the community center’s annual operating budget, currently more than $1 million dollars a year, through a joint operating agreement signed in 2013 by the late Precinct 1 Commissioner El Franco Lee.

The model of relying on one entity for a majority of Hester House’s budget is indicative of the board’s failure to secure a broad pool of funding sources, Woods said.

Asked about the reliance on county funding, Brown said fundraising has been a longstanding challenge for Hester House, because of the center’s mission of offering mostly no- or low-cost programming for children and senior citizens. 

If the county already provides upwards of 90 percent of the center’s funding, why does that model have to change, residents ask.

At the Dec. 19 community meeting, Ellis told the audience the existing agreement could not remain in place because of legal concerns from County Attorney Christian Menefee. 

Harris County Attorney, Christian Menefee, and Jonathan Fombonne, deputy county attorney & first assistant county attorney on April 18, 2024, in the 165th District Court in Houston. (Houston Landing file photo / Meridith Kohut)

A list of talking points obtained by the Houston Landing through an open records request outlines Ellis’ planned remarks for that meeting, noting Menefee’s concerns stem from Precinct 1 providing the lion’s share of funding outside the county’s procurement process for a facility it does not own.

“The county attorney’s office has told us in writing that they will not support, and have serious concerns about the legality of the current arrangement between Harris County and Hester House,” it reads.

The proposed donation, it continues, is a way for the county to continue funding Hester House while also following the law. 

In a written statement, a spokesperson for Menefee’s office said the county attorney is working with all involved parties to find a solution. 

Obstacles and next steps

In January, Brown said executing the donation would be a lengthy process. 

The first step, he said, will be drafting a legal document formalizing the donation. 

Then, the county and Hester House would need to begin the process of determining which financial assets can be transferred from the community center into a specific line item in the county’s budget. The financial piece, Brown said, would take at least a couple months. 

MORE ON HESTER HOUSE: Preserving history: Fifth Ward seniors share memories of Hester House in new documentary

While Brown continues to work out the details with Harris County, recent developments have put some of that on the back burner. 

Earlier this month, soil testing conducted as part of the Environmental Protection Agency’s ongoing investigation into the Fifth Ward cancer cluster found elevated levels of cancer-causing toxins in the soil near Hester House’s daycare. The area since has been fenced off, and further testing will be conducted to determine if a cleanup is needed. 

The EPA will host a community meeting on Feb. 27 to discuss the test results.

A Union Pacific train is seen parked on the tracks through Sandra Auzenne’s kitchen window, Wednesday, Nov. 29, 2023, in Greater Fifth Ward, Houston. (Houston Landing file photo / Antranik Tavitian)

In addition to the environmental concerns comes a political one:  State Rep. Harold Dutton, D-Houston, filed a bill last week to turn Hester House and the 4.7 acres it sits on into a state park. 

It is unclear how Dutton’s bill, if passed, would impact the potential donation or the community center’s programming. The representative did not respond to multiple requests for comment. 

Dutton, who is a member of Hester House’s board of directors, voted against beginning the donation process back in December. 

He spoke about his reasoning for voting against the donation at a second community meeting on Feb. 8, saying he wanted to ensure every option was explored. 

Brown said he had concerns about turning Hester House over to state control.

Confederate Heroes Day, celebrated on Jan. 19, is a state holiday in Texas. Should Hester House become a state park, Brown said he is worried the community center would be forced to recognize the holiday, flying in the face of its deep ties to Houston’s Black community.

Ella Wardsworth, at right, plays with Giavonni Spears, 1, during a choir practice at Hester House, Tuesday, Nov. 19, 2024, in Houston. (Houston Landing file photo / Antranik Tavitian)

Despite his concern, Brown said Dutton’s bill is indicative of his love for the nonprofit.

“It shows his commitment to Hester House, to trying to figure out long term sustainability,” Brown said. 

Ellis, in a written statement, also expressed concern.

“My only priority is ensuring that Hester House survives and thrives for future generations,” He said. “…But let’s be clear: the State of Texas has made a habit of rewriting history, erasing the contributions of Black communities, and waging war on DEI. That reality cannot be ignored when discussing the future of Hester House, the last standing Black settlement house in Harris County, a space that has long been a crucible for Black social and political movements.”

Despite his own reservations, Brown said he would present Dutton’s proposal to the board for consideration. 

All options for securing Hester House’s future are on the table, he said.

Without the county’s funding, though, Brown worries the community center’s financial runway is not very long.

“Unfortunately,” he said, “it always gets to the dollars.”

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print.

Tim Carlin is the Houston Landing's government solutions reporter. An Ohio native, Tim comes to Houston after spending a year in Greenville, South Carolina, covering Greenville County government for The...